LiveRisk-On · 69Vol: moderateVIX 15.44DXY 99.87S&P +1.11%Gold +1.83%JPY strength -0.1910Y-2Y spread 0.46Updated 22m agoFull regime data →
Indicators / Advanced Supply Demand vs Waddah Attar Explosion
Indicator comparison

Advanced Supply Demand vs Waddah Attar Explosion

A side-by-side look at Advanced Supply Demand and Waddah Attar Explosion on repaint behavior, signal type, platform, and timeframe, pulled straight from each review.

★★★★★3.9vs★★★★★4.0
FBFX Score 90/100 FBFX Score 90/100
Advanced Supply DemandWaddah Attar Explosion
PlatformMT4, MT5MT4, MT5
RepaintsNoNo
Signal typeLeadingLeading
Best timeframeH4H1
Best pairsForex majors, metals, indices, and crypto pairs, per vendor listingAny liquid forex pair; commonly run on majors like EUR/USD and GBP/USD
Advanced Supply Demand
+ Zones are anchored to the bars where the imbalance formed, so a drawn zone does not slide to a new price later
+ Detects supply and demand zones across multiple timeframes from a single chart
+ Customizable on-chart control panel with the option to hide or show it entirely
+ Includes ADR high/low lines and proximity alerts (screen and push notification) built into the same package
- Zones are backpainted by construction, so scrolling back through history makes them look more reliable than they were in real time
- A zone is a range rather than a level, so two traders using identical settings can disagree about where inside it to enter or place a stop
- Zone counts build up quickly on lower timeframes and clutter the chart unless you cap how many are displayed
Waddah Attar Explosion
+ Free to download, with the original version published in the public MQL5 Code Base since 2007
+ Calculation is public, so repaint behaviour can be settled by inspecting the formula rather than trusting a vendor claim
+ Combines two well-understood tools, MACD and Bollinger Bands, into one visual momentum-and-volatility read
+ Fully adjustable sensitivity, dead zone, and trend power inputs for tuning signal frequency
- Being MACD-derived, it inherits the lag of any moving-average-based calculation and will not call a move before it starts
- The dead zone is an absolute pip threshold, so a setting tuned on one instrument behaves completely differently on another
- Widely copied and re-hosted across download sites, so the build you download may differ from the original published code
Verdict

Advanced Supply Demand and Waddah Attar Explosion are compared side by side above on repaint behavior, signal type, and platform. Check the table for the specifics that matter to your setup.

Frequently asked
Which is better, Advanced Supply Demand or Waddah Attar Explosion?

Advanced Supply Demand scores 90/100 on the FirstBuckFX Score and Waddah Attar Explosion scores 90/100, both computed from repaint behavior, signal specificity, and disclosure on each indicator's review page.

Ready to look closer
Advanced Supply Demand
★★★★★3.9
Read the full Advanced Supply Demand review →
Waddah Attar Explosion
★★★★★4.0
Read the full Waddah Attar Explosion review →
← Back to all indicator reviews