LiveRisk-On · 69Vol: moderateVIX 15.44DXY 99.87S&P +1.11%Gold +1.83%JPY strength -0.1910Y-2Y spread 0.46Updated 22m agoFull regime data →
Indicators / Advanced Supply Demand vs Gold Stuff
Indicator comparison

Advanced Supply Demand vs Gold Stuff

A side-by-side look at Advanced Supply Demand and Gold Stuff on repaint behavior, signal type, platform, and timeframe, pulled straight from each review.

3.9vs3.6
FBFX Score 90/100 FBFX Score 74/100
Advanced Supply DemandGold Stuff
PlatformMT4, MT5MT4, MT5
RepaintsNoUnknown
Signal typeLeadingTrend
Best timeframeH4H1 (the author's stated recommendation)
Best pairsForex majors, metals, indices, and crypto pairs, per vendor listingXAU/USD (Gold); the author states it also runs on any other instrument
Advanced Supply Demand
+ Zones are anchored to the bars where the imbalance formed, so a drawn zone does not slide to a new price later
+ Detects supply and demand zones across multiple timeframes from a single chart
+ Customizable on-chart control panel with the option to hide or show it entirely
+ Includes ADR high/low lines and proximity alerts (screen and push notification) built into the same package
- Zones are backpainted by construction, so scrolling back through history makes them look more reliable than they were in real time
- A zone is a range rather than a level, so two traders using identical settings can disagree about where inside it to enter or place a stop
- Zone counts build up quickly on lower timeframes and clutter the chart unless you cap how many are displayed
Gold Stuff
+ Cheap for a paid MQL5 Market indicator: 30 USD on MT4 and 50 USD on MT5, both one-off
+ A free demo of each build runs in the MT4 and MT5 strategy tester, so the behaviour can be checked before paying
+ Almost nothing to configure, which removes the temptation to tune settings until the history looks good
+ Long public feedback trail on the marketplace: roughly 600 reviews and 1,200 comments across the two builds
- The calculation is closed, so the no-redraw claim cannot be settled by reading it and has to be tested on your own charts
- No period, sensitivity or threshold inputs at all, so it cannot be adapted to an instrument it was not tuned for
- Both builds last shipped a version in March 2023, so the listing is stable rather than actively developed
Verdict

Advanced Supply Demand carries the higher FirstBuckFX Score, 90/100 against 74/100 for Gold Stuff.

Frequently asked
Which is better, Advanced Supply Demand or Gold Stuff?

Advanced Supply Demand scores 90/100 on the FirstBuckFX Score and Gold Stuff scores 74/100, both computed from repaint behavior, signal specificity, and disclosure on each indicator's review page.

Ready to look closer
Advanced Supply Demand
3.9
Read the full Advanced Supply Demand review →
Gold Stuff
3.6
Read the full Gold Stuff review →
← Back to all indicator reviews